With a breakout cast and creative team behind Data, this collection reflects the taste of artists shaping theatre today. Featuring Karan Brar, Justin H. Min, Brandon Flynn, Sophia Lillis, plus playwright Matthew Libby and director Tyne Rafaeli.

NY | TT | Tastemaker | Data Cast + Creative

Data Cast Collection Imagery

A lineup of daring, genre-bending shows that break rules and redefine theater. Weird, bold, and unforgettable. This is New York at its most original.

NY | TT | Theme | Edgy & unique

Collection Image - Edgy

VenueNameNoLink

Step outside the box with our Edgy & Unique collection. Discover immersive theater, experimental plays, and unconventional performances across New York City.

Edgy & Unique NYC Shows | Bold Off-Broadway & Experimental Theater | TodayTix

Stories of love, fate, and ambition told on the grandest scale. These are sweeping dramas and timeless tragedies that stir the soul, from mythic journeys to modern revolutions. Each one reminds you why some stories echo long after the curtain falls.

NY | TT | Theme | Tragedy & Triumph

Tragedy and Triumph Collection Image

None

Experience the heights of human emotion. This collection features gripping dramas and epic tales of resilience currently performing on Broadway and beyond.

Tragedy & Triumph on Stage | Powerful Dramas & Epic NYC Plays | TodayTix

The city’s highest bar for excellence. We’ve curated the essential plays and musicals currently holding this seal, offering a guide to the visceral and daring stories defining the cultural conversation right now.

NY | TT | Theme | NYT Critics' Picks

Collection Image - Critics Picks

Score

See the shows the critics love. Shop The New York Times Critics’ Picks for the best-reviewed theater, from Broadway blockbusters to Off-Broadway gems.

NYT Critics’ Picks NYC | Top-Rated Broadway & Off-Broadway Shows | TodayTix

Ben has done it all—from starring on Broadway to producing new hits. Here are his must-see shows right now.

NY | TT | Tastemaker | Ben Platt

Ben Platt - Collection Image

ScoreAndAge

Shop the personal favorites of Tony-winner Ben Platt. From brilliant new scores to stellar performances, discover the NYC shows that Ben recommends right now.

Ben Platt’s NYC Theater Favorites | Actor-Curated Stage Hits | TodayTix

"When I first moved to New York two years ago, the first show I saw was Oh, Mary! at the Lucille Lortel. It's since moved to Broadway, which is so exciting. And if you're visiting New York, you have to see that show. It's brilliant." - Karan Brar

NY | TT | Collections | DATA | Oh, Mary! | 37743

Ages 14+. Children under 4 are not permitted in the theater.

Oh, Mary! on Broadway - NYC [37743]

Genre: Play

Oh, Mary! on Broadway

Oh, Mary! - Product Media - App Hero Image

Oh, Mary! - NYC  - Product Media

Oh, Mary!  - Product Media - Header Image

A woman in a long black dress stands in a doorway, leaning forward with arms outstretched, in a room with patterned wallpaper, bookshelves, and a fireplace.

Oh, Mary! - Product Media - Image - Asset 1

A woman in a black Victorian-style dress dramatically enters a room through double doors, appearing on a stage with patterned wallpaper and bookshelves.

A person in a black Victorian-style dress and bonnet stands alone in front of large, closed purple curtains with gold fringe at the bottom.

Oh, Mary! - Product Media - Image - Asset 2

Three actors in period costumes perform energetically in a vintage room with blue wallpaper and a portrait of George Washington above a mantel.

Oh, Mary! - Product Media - Image - Asset 3

Two people dressed in 19th-century formal attire stand in a theater box with gold curtains and an American flag visible on the right.

Oh, Mary! - Product Media - Image - Asset 4

Four actors in period costumes sit and converse animatedly onstage in a Victorian-style room with patterned wallpaper, a window, and ornate furniture.

Oh, Mary! - Product Media - Image - Asset 5

A woman in a formal black dress sits on a couch while a man in period costume kneels beside her, gesturing as they talk in a room with patterned wallpaper and double doors.

Oh, Mary! - Product Media - Image - Asset 6

Two women in Victorian-style dresses sit indoors; one in pastel colors gestures expressively with a handkerchief, while the other in black sits with arms crossed and an unimpressed expression.

Oh, Mary! - Product Media - Image - Asset 7

Two women in elaborate Victorian-style dresses sit side by side; one gestures with a handkerchief, the other sits with arms crossed, looking stern, against a patterned wall in a formal room.

Oh, Mary! - Product Media - Poster Image

Oh, Mary! - Product Media - Poster Image (Square)

Cole Escola moved to New York for college and, after dropping out, found their way into the city’s comedy scene. In 2008, Escola met comedian Jeffery Self, who shared their passions for theatre and ‘90s sitcoms, inspiring them to create a YouTube series as the "Very Good Looking (VGL) Gay Boys." Following the cult success of their videos, they received their own TV show on Logo, *Jeffery & Cole Casserole*, which ran for two seasons. Escola later had roles on *Difficult People*, *Search Party*, *Big Mouth*, *At Home with Amy Sedaris* (which earned them a Writers Guild Award), and more before writing and leading the original cast of *Oh, Mary!*

Beyond acting, Escola wrote for comedy TV shows like *Ziwe*, *The Other Two*, and *Difficult People*. In 2021, they released a YouTube rendition of their live special "Help! I'm Stuck With Cole Escola" and, in 2023, they released an homage to '70s westerns on YouTube called "Our Home Out West." Vanity Fair added Escola’s performance to its 25 Best Performances of 2023 list.

## What to watch for

- While *Oh, Mary!* marks Escola’s Broadway debut, they’re no stranger to performing in New York. The Public Theater’s Joe’s Pub was a stop on the tour of their live solo show *Help! I'm Stuck.* 
- Numerous Hollywood actresses have played Mary Todd Lincoln in film and television adaptations of President Abraham Lincoln’s life. They include Mary Tyler Moore, Sally Field, Donna Murphy, and Mary Elizabeth Winstead. 
- Director Sam Pinkleton is best known as a Broadway choreographer for hit musicals like *Amelie* and *Natasha, Pierre & the Great Comet of 1812*, for which he earned a Tony Award nomination.
- *Oh, Mary!* features original music by Daniel Kluger, a Tony-nominated composer, orchestrator, and sound designer known for his work on shows like *The Sound Inside*, *Significant Other*, and the 2019 revival of *Oklahoma!*

## Important information

- Children under 4 are not permitted in the theatre.
- This production uses a gunshot sound effect. This production uses theatrical haze and smoke.
- No weapons permitted on the premises. No outside food or beverages, electric scooters, e-bikes, or battery-powered transportation devices, except when medically necessary.
- All items are subject to inspection. Anything brought into the theatre must fit on your lap or completely under your seat without blocking any aisles. Avoid bringing packages, luggage, and backpacks. Some items must be checked.
- The use of cameras, cell phones, and other recording devices during the show is strictly prohibited by law, except when used for accessibility services.

__Audio Described / Captioned Performances__<br>
The theatre offers automated closed captioning and audio description via I-Caption or on your personal mobile device with the GalaPro App.

Mary Rush

Enter for a chance to purchase {display price} {show} tickets.

{display price} Lottery tickets

If selected, you will have [CLAIM LENGTH] to purchase [PRICE] [SHOW TITLE] tickets.

Download our app to enter the Lottery for a chance to purchase {display price} tickets.

I entered the [SHOW] Lottery for [DISPLAY_PRICE] tickets on @TodayTix! Tap here to enter: https://www.todaytix.com/[LOCATION]/shows/[ID]?share=enter

Unlock Rush for a chance to purchase $43 tickets at 9:00 am.

$43 Rush tickets

Download our app to unlock Rush for a chance at last-minute tickets for only $43.

OhMary-FBTW-Rush 1200x627

OhMary-IG-Rush 1080x1920

oh mary2

Company may offer programs whereby the Company would make available certain features of the Services when you share information about the Services through an SNS or click on the “Unlock without sharing” button in the Application.  When you are considering purchasing a ticket for a specific show or after you purchase a ticket, if you select the “Share” button in the Application, Company will make available to you a personalized link to a Digital Property with text stating, for example, “Check out {show} on TodayTix! I’m thinking of going…” or something similar, which you may choose to share with your friends via SNS.  Once you have shared the personalized link through an SNS using the Application or selected the “Unlock without sharing” button in the Application, Company will make available to you the RUSH feature, which will provide you with otherwise unavailable offers for tickets to live events occurring in the next week. The opportunity to take advantage of these offers is only available to users who share a personalized link to an SNS through the Application or select the “Unlock without sharing” button in the Application.

I unlocked $43 Rush tickets for Oh, Mary on @TodayTix! https://www.todaytix.com/nyc/shows/37743?share=unlock

Oh, Mary! - NYC - TT

See this historical dark comedy, now nominated for five Tony Awards, about the untold struggles of Mary Todd Lincoln before she lost Abe. Get a glimpse into Mary's hidden desires and personal struggles, filtered through queer comic playwright Cole Escola's wacky mind.

Maya Rudolph makes her Broadway debut as Mary Todd Lincoln through July 5 only! The critically acclaimed play from Tony Award-winning comedian, writer, and actor Cole Escola (*Search Party*) sheds light on the lesser-known story of Mary Todd Lincoln as never before. Get *Oh, Mary!* tickets on New York Theatre Guide now.

## What is *Oh, Mary!* about?

*Oh, Mary!* explores the inner conflicts of Mary Todd Lincoln in the days preceding her husband’s tragic assassination, an event that changed American history forever. Promising a distinctive exploration of historical intrigue and personal turmoil, the *Oh, Mary!* play offers insight into one of history’s most enigmatic figures through a funny, surreal lens. Tony Award nominee Sam Pinkleton directs.

## Who is Cole Escola?

Cole Escola — who wrote and won a Tony Award for originally playing the title role of *Oh, Mary!*, is an actor, writer, and comedian who found their path in New York City’s comedy circuit. In 2008, Escola met comedian Jeffery Self, who shared Escola’s love for theatre and '90s sitcoms, motivating the pair to create a series of YouTube videos as the "Very Good Looking (VGL) Gay Boys." Following the videos’ cult success, Escola and Self launched their own TV show on Logo named *Jeffery & Cole Casserole*, which ran for two seasons. Escola subsequently appeared in shows like *Difficult People*, *Search Party*, *At Home with Amy Sedaris*, *Big Mouth*, and more.

Apart from acting, Escola wrote for comedy TV programs like *Ziwe*, *The Other Two*, and *Difficult People*. In 2021, they released a YouTube version of their live special "Help! I'm Stuck With Cole Escola," and in 2023, they presented a YouTube homage to '70s Westerns titled "Our Home Out West," which earned Escola a place in Vanity Fair’s 25 Best Performances of 2023 list.

Get tickets to *Oh, Mary!* in New York.

Oh, Mary! - NYC - NYTG

Oh, Mary! Broadway Tickets | The Official NY Theatre Guide

This dark comedy shines a spotlight on Mary Todd Lincoln and the challenges she faced in her time as First Lady — but with plenty of irreverent, silly twists. This intimate portrayal of Mary's internal struggles takes on a new character through queer comic playwright Cole Escola's unconventional perspective. Now nominated for five Tony Awards.

Meg Stalter makes her Broadway debut as Mary Todd Lincoln in [*Oh, Mary!*](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/show/37743-oh-mary) on Broadway at the [Lyceum Theatre](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/venues/lyceum-theatre-ny) from July 6 to September 12, 2026.

Stalter is an actress and comedian best known for her breakout performance as Kayla Schaefer on the Emmy-winning HBO Max series *Hacks*. Her other TV credits include Netflix's *Too Much* and Peacock's *Queer as Folk* reboot, and she forayed into theatre with the comedy show *An Evening of Mayhem with Megan Stalter* at the 2023 Edinburgh Fringe Festival.

Meg Stalter - NY

stalter

Phillip James Brannon stars as Mary's Husband in [*Oh, Mary!*](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/show/37743-oh-mary) on Broadway at the [Lyceum Theatre](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/theatres/lyceum-theatre-ny).

Brannon previously played Mary's Husband earlier in 2025 opposite Betty Gilpin in the title role. Additional Broadway credits include the plays *Macbeth* and *Junk*, and he earned an Obie Award alongside his cast for performing in the Off-Broadway show *The Fires*.

Brannon has appeared on TV shows including *The Good Fight, Elementary, The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel*, and *Law & Order: SVU*.

Phillip James Brannon - NY

Macbeth on Broadway - NYC

Macbeth on Broadway

Junk [6705]

Junk

brannon

Bianca Leigh stars as Mary's Chaperone in [*Oh, Mary!*](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/show/37743-oh-mary) on Broadway at the [Lyceum Theatre](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/venues/lyceum-theatre-ny).

Leigh has performed on Broadway in *The Nap*, and on screen in the films *Transamerica*, *Hurricane Bianca*, and its sequel *Hurricane Bianca: From Russia with Hate*. She originated the role of Louise (Mary's Chaperone) in Cole Escola's *Oh, Mary!* off Broadway before transferring to Broadway with the production.

Bianca Leigh - NYC 

bianca

The Lyceum Theatre is one of Broadway's longest running, and most storied venues. It is the oldest continually operating theatre in New York City, delivering its rich tradition and history since opening its doors in 1903. Uniquely, it is one of the few theatres that was built and still operates as a legitimate theatre. The stunning Beaux-Arts style facade and grandiose interior, designed by architects Herts & Tallant, are part of what make a night at Lyceum truly unforgettable one. The theatre has been home to a vast array of productions, from plays to musicals, and has played a key role in shaping the Broadway landscape. Some of the notable performances include 'The Voice Of The Turtle', 'Othello', 'Born Yesterday', and more recently, the Tony award-winning 'The Play That Goes Wrong'. 

 ## How to Get to the Venue 
 The Lyceum Theatre is prominently situated at 149 W 45th Street, almost in the very heart of Manhattan. It is well-serviced by public transport with several subway stations nearby - Times Square-42nd St (N,Q,R,S,1,2,3,7), 42nd St-Bryant Park (B,D,F,M), and 47th-50th streets-Rockefeller Center (B,D,F,M). Taxis and ride-share services like Uber are also readily available. Given its central location, it is also easily reachable by foot if you're already downtown.

Lyceum Theatre - NY

Lyceum theatre 1600x1200

Lyceum Theatre 

NY - Broadway

Broadway Shows in NYC

Every Broadway show now on sale. Same-day Rush tickets, Lottery entries, and last-minute deals on TodayTix.

Broadway Shows & Tickets | Same-Day Rush & Lottery | TodayTix

New York All Shows

Get last-minute theatre tickets for New York Shows at the best prices, and get exclusive access to our Lottery and Rush tickets.

Last-Minute Broadway Tickets & Theatre in NYC | New York Shows | TodayTix

New York Shows

NY - Why TT

NY - Why TT - Desktop

NY - Why TT - Mobile

Get tickets to the best shows at the best prices on Broadway and beyond

Curated picks from editors and insiders. Save collections for updates and new releases.

NY | TT | Collections Landing Page

Discover New York City

Latest New York City Insider Posts 

New York

Venues in New York City

Explore curated NYC theatre collections. From Tony-winning musicals to celebrity casts, our expert guides help you discover and book the best shows in New York.

NYC Theatre Collections: Expert Guides to Broadway & More | TodayTix

New York Header Image

Explore Broadway and Off-Broadway news and reviews, and book the best NYC events.

New York Theatre Guide Home Page (New York Theatre Guide)

New York Theatre Guide – Official site for theatre tickets & news

See what's on sale on Broadway, from classics to new hits. Get tickets today. Find tickets at New York Theatre Guide, a reliable source for Broadway.

New York Theatre Guide - New York Musicals & Plays

New York Search Results

Search Results

New York Tile Image

TodayTix App Home - NYC 

New York Home Page (TT Home)

NY - All Shows

All shows in New York

Browse Broadway, Off-Broadway, and live events in NYC. Same-day Rush tickets and Lottery on TodayTix.

NYC Shows & Tickets — Broadway, Off-Broadway & More | TodayTix

New York Nav Links [NEW]

More shows

New York Home Page (WL)

WL Newsletter

WL NYC Nav

Lyceum Theatre  - TodayTix

The Lyceum Theatre is Broadway's oldest continually operating theatre. Designed by Herts & Tallant and built by producer-manager David Frohman, the theatre officially opened on November 2, 1903. It was a replacement for Frohman's previous Lyceum Theatre on Fourth Street, which closed in 1902.

The inaugural production at the venue was the play *The Proud Prince*. The Lyceum Theatre was purchased in 1940 by a conglomerate of producers which included George S. Kaufman and Moss Hart, and in 1950, the Shubert Organization took ownership of the theatre. In 1974, the Lyceum Theatre became the first Broadway theatre to be granted landmark status.

## How to get to the Lyceum Theatre on Broadway

The Lyceum Theatre is closest to the 42nd Street - Times Square subway stop on the 1, 2, 3, 7, N, Q, R, W, and S lines. The closest bus stops are 6th Ave/W 44th St. on the M55, QM2, QM3, QM4, QM15, QM16, QM17, QM18, and QM20 lines; and 6th Ave/West 45th St. on the QM1, QM5, QM6, M5, and M7 lines.

## Restaurants near the Lyceum Theatre

Popular restaurants near the Lyceum Theatre include Havana Central (Cuban), Carmine's (Italian), Connolly's Irish pub, and Junior's (American). [Learn more about popular pre- and post-show restaurants in the Theatre District.](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/theatre-news/news/where-to-eat-before-and-after-a-broadway-show)

Lyceum Theatre  - New York Theatre Guide

The Lyceum Theatre, Broadway's oldest, opened in 1903. Now owned by the Shubert Organization, it's closest to 42nd Street - Times Square subway stop.

Seating chart of a theater showing stage, orchestra, mezzanine, balcony, and box sections, with labeled seat rows in each area.

Lyceum Theatre - NYC - 1326 x1406 px

What's on at Lyceum Theatre Ny in New York City. Browse upcoming shows, check showtimes, and get tickets on TodayTix.

Lyceum Theatre Ny — Shows & Tickets | NYC | TodayTix

The Lyceum Theatre is New York's oldest operating theatre, opening in 1903. It's central location allows for easy access with public transport.

E-ticket

Save with limited-time offers on tickets for this show.

US - Special offer (Shubert)

History

Award winners

Broadway

Must-See

Stars on Stage

Comedy

Transfer

"Check out Peyton List in Heathers. I heard she's going to be amazing in that!" - Karan Brar

NY | TT | Collections | DATA | Heathers | 42261

Ages 14+. Children under 4 years old will not be admitted.

Heathers The Musical - NYC [42261]

Heathers The Musical

14102 Heathers-Todaytix-Assets 1440x580 (1)

14102 Heathers-Todaytix-Assets 1600x1200 (1)

Heathers The Musical - Product Media - Image - Asset 1

A person in a long dark coat stands in front of a 7-Eleven Slurpee machine display, holding a cup and smiling with one hand raised near their head.

Heathers The Musical - Product Media - Image - Asset 2

Two actors on stage: a young woman in a blue blazer and plaid skirt stands in front, while a young man in a black jacket hugs her from behind.

Heathers The Musical - Product Media - Image - Asset 3

Four young women in colorful, coordinated outfits stand close together on stage, with one woman in red gesturing dramatically toward the woman in the center.

Heathers The Musical - Product Media - Image - Asset 4

Three women in colorful plaid school uniforms—green, red, and yellow—stand on stage in dramatic poses with a purple-lit background and smoke effects behind them.

Heathers The Musical - Product Media - Image - Asset 5

14102 Heathers-Todaytix-Assets 480x720 (1)

Poster of Heathers The Musical in New York.

14102 Heathers-Todaytix-Assets 1080x1080 (1)

*Heathers* is a dark musical comedy that’s, in wonderful and campy ways, partly a satire of high school life. This comes as no surprise looking at the creators, Kevin Murphy and Laurence O’Keefe, who have created high-octane hits like *Legally Blonde, Bat Boy*, and *Reefer Madness*. Like those shows, *Heathers* showcases young characters contending with the pains of adolescence and growing up. The musical, like the movie, does not shy away from heavier material: suicide, mental health, body image issues, and drug use are all addressed. 

Nonetheless, there are many laughs along the way — and hit songs like “Seventeen,” “Lifeboat,” and “Freeze Your Brain.”. A precursor to the film *Mean Girls* (and its subsequent stage show), *Heathers* was ahead of its time as a late-80s film that continues to resonate with young audiences today. London Theatre raved, “This musical has the power to tap into all of the tempestuous emotions associated with being a teenager.”

The *Heathers* musical first premiered in 2013 in Los Angeles before running off Broadway the following year. This new production originated in 2018 in London's West End before going on to have two national tours and an encore engagement in the West End.

## What to watch for

- One line from the movie — "I don't patronize bunny rabbits" — was cut from the musical until Winona Ryder saw the show in L.A. and asked that it be added back in. It's remained in every major production since!
- One character, Ms. Fleming, ad-libs a section of the song "Shine a Light" at every performance, and it's different every night.
- In various scenes, the ensemble appears in white robes and 3-D glasses, a direct nod to the costuming in a key scene from the movie.
- One scene takes place in a cow pasture dubbed "Lehmann's Farm," a nod to *Heathers* film director Michael Lehmann.
- The original film starred Winona Ryder, Christian Slater, Shannen Doherty, Lisanne Falk, Kim Walker, and Penelope Milford.

## Important information

- This production uses loud sound effects including gun shots.
- This production uses theatrical haze and smoke.
- Strobe or flashing lights are used in this production.
- Contains strong language and mature themes including murder, suicide, sexual violence and references to eating disorders. Audience discretion is advised.
- Children under 4 years old will not be admitted.
- No weapons permitted on the premises. No outside food or beverages, electric scooters, e-bikes, or battery-powered transportation devices, except when medically necessary.
- All items are subject to inspection. Anything brought into the theatre must fit on your lap or completely under your seat without blocking any aisles. Avoid bringing packages, luggage, and backpacks. Some items must be checked.
- The use of cameras, cell phones, and other recording devices during the show is strictly prohibited by law, except when used for accessibility services.

Heathers The Musical - NYC - Todaytix

*Heathers* is a musical comedy based on the cult film and follows Veronica as she tries to navigate teenage issues, first love, and three Heathers who rule the school with an iron fist.

Get ready for big fun at *Heathers The Musical*, returning to New York City 10 years after its original Off-Broadway premiere and fresh off multiple acclaimed runs in the U.K. Get *Heathers* tickets now.

In *Heathers*, based on the hit 1988 film, Veronica Sawyer navigates the dicey waters of Westerberg High School: her friend is bullied for being fat; she crushes on a mysterious, brooding boy who might have a deadly streak; and the Heathers clique reigns supreme. A trio of girls all with the first name Heather are conniving, thorny, and all-powerful. Will Veronica be able to beat the Heathers at their own game without losing herself along the way?

*Heathers* features hit songs like “Seventeen,” “Lifeboat,” and “Freeze Your Brain” in this adaptation by Kevin Murphy and Laurence O’Keefe, two musical theatre writers who know how to write fun, campy roles and songs for young artists — especially in shows that are stage adaptations. Murphy wrote the book and lyrics for *Reefer Madness*, and O’Keefe wrote the music and lyrics for *Legally Blonde*.

Despite those energetic musicals, *Heathers* does deal with darker themes, including body image issues, suicide, bullying, and more. However, such issues are what make the musical popular amongst a younger generation.

“Its darkly comedic storyline about high school growing pains still bites,” London Theatre raved in a four-star review. “There’s a reason these young fans keep coming back to the show, regardless of where it is staged. This musical has the power to tap into all of the tempestuous emotions associated with being a teenager.”

Do you have what it takes to survive the Heathers? Get tickets to *Heathers The Musical* to find out.

## Important information

- This production uses loud sound effects including gun shots.
- This production uses theatrical haze and smoke.
- Strobe or flashing lights are used in this production.
- Contains strong language and mature themes including murder, suicide, sexual violence and references to eating disorders. Audience discretion is advised.
- Children under 4 years old will not be admitted.
- No weapons permitted on the premises. No outside food or beverages, electric scooters, e-bikes, or battery-powered transportation devices, except when medically necessary.
- All items are subject to inspection. Anything brought into the theatre must fit on your lap or completely under your seat without blocking any aisles. Avoid bringing packages, luggage, and backpacks. Some items must be checked.
- The use of cameras, cell phones, and other recording devices during the show is strictly prohibited by law, except when used for accessibility services.

Heathers The Musical  - NYC - NYTG

*Heathers* is a dark comedy and musical based on the cult 1989 film. It follows Veronica Sawyer, a student who navigates social hierarchy and teenage issues in her high school, run by a trio of popular girls all named Heather.

Isabella Esler stars as Veronica Sawyer in [*Heathers The Musical*](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/show/42261-heathers-the-musical) off Broadway at [New World Stages](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/venues/new-world-stages) from April 27, 2026.

Esler made her Broadway debut as Lydia in [*Beetlejuice*](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/show/14894-beetlejuice-musical-tickets) in 2025 after playing the role on the show's national tour. For starring as Alice Carter in the musical *Life After* in Toronto, she was nominated for Outstanding Performance by an Individual at the 2025 Dora Awards.

Isabella Esler - NYC

Ages 13+. Due to strong language and mature themes.

Beetlejuice on Broadway - NYC [14894]

Beetlejuice on Broadway

esler

John Cardoza stars as J.D. in [*Heathers The Musical*](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/show/42261-heathers-the-musical) off Broadway at [New World Stages](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/venues/new-world-stages) from April 27, 2026.

Cardoza made his Broadway debut in the ensemble of the Alanis Morissette musical *Jagged Little Pill* and went on to star as Younger Noah in the 2024 Broadway musical adaptation of Nicholas Sparks's *The Notebook*. He also played Christian in [*Moulin Rouge! The Musical*](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/show/15911-moulin-rouge-the-musical-on-broadway-tickets) on Broadway and in the show's U.S. national tour.

John Cardoza - NY

Ages 10+. Children under 4 are not permitted in the theatre.

The Notebook: The Musical on Broadway - NYC [33744]

The Notebook: The Musical on Broadway

The 2-time Tony Award® winning show based on Alanis Morissette’s iconic music. 

Jagged Little Pill on Broadway [16570]

Jagged Little Pill on Broadway

Hold Me in the Water - NYC [41046]

Hold Me in the Water

Ages 12+. Children under 5 years old will not be admitted.

Moulin Rouge! The Musical on Broadway - NYC [15911]

Moulin Rouge! The Musical on Broadway

john 200

Zan Berube stars as Heather Chandler in [*Heathers The Musical*](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/show/42261-heathers-the-musical) off Broadway at [New World Stages](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/venues/new-world-stages) from April 27, 2026. Berube has also starred in the national tours of *Back to the Future: The Musical* as Lorraine Baines and *Six* as Anne Boleyn.

Zan Berube - NY

Jackera Davis stars as Heather Duke in [*Heathers The Musical*](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/show/42261-heathers-the-musical) off Broadway at [New World Stages](https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/venues/new-world-stages) from December 11, 2025.

Davis makes her Off-Broadway debut with *Heathers*. She has previously performed in the national tour of *Beetlejuice* and in regional productions like *All Shook Up* at Goodspeed Musicals, *Bye Bye Birdie* at the Kennedy Center, and *Footloose* at Sacramento Music Circus.

Jackera Davis - NY

jackera

Discover the shows trending with the cast and creative team of "Data." Browse this insider-curated collection of top-tier Broadway and Off-Broadway productions.

The Data Cast & Creatives Collection

Discover more collections